This past weekend I had the opportunity to attend the highly anticipated Orchestra Noir show in Jacksonville Florida and let me tell you the house was packed. I’m pretty sure the event was sold out. Now before I jump into this review let me just say one thing about me, I’m a tough critic. Getting a 10 out of 10 from me is rare. I don’t hand those out like candy. So when I do give a perfect score just know it’s the real deal. Now with that said let’s get into the details of the night.
Let’s Talk About the Pros First
One thing I appreciated right off the bat was the show starting about 30 minutes after the scheduled time. That might sound odd to some but if you’ve ever been to a predominantly Black event you already know the vibes. That extra time gave folks a chance to grab their drinks get settled and enjoy the moment without feeling rushed. When the show did start, the orchestra looked amazing. Everyone was in black tie and it really set a classy elegant tone for the evening. The musicians are clearly talented and the arrangements for the most part were solid. There were moments where the music really shined and had people swaying in their seats.
Now Let’s Get Into the Cons
While I loved the concept, I have to be honest about some things that didn’t quite hit the mark for me. The music director also served as the host which I didn’t love. There was just way too much talking and not enough playing. I came for the music not the commentary. The performances were divided into two halves with the first part covering hits from the 1990s and the second half focusing on the 2000s.
Some songs in the first half were beautifully done but a few went on a bit too long. When you’re listening to instrumentals without vocals four minutes can feel like an eternity. I found myself waiting for more iconic hits and quicker transitions between songs.
Now the second half is where I really started to feel disconnected. There was a thirty-minute intermission where a DJ played hip hop tracks which seemed like a lead-in to the next part of the show. But once it started it felt less like an orchestra and more like a high-energy marching band. Where did the R&B go? Where were the smooth soulful vibes that made the 2000s such a golden era?
I was expecting a night of classical R&B with beautiful string arrangements of artists like Usher, Ne-Yo, and Chris Brown to name a few. Instead I got loud horns and heavy beats with barely any strings. And the few strings I did hear felt out of place like they were trying too hard to fit into songs they didn’t belong in. It was disappointing especially because the talent was clearly there but the song selection and arrangements just missed the mark.
Final Thoughts
If Orchestra Noir returns to Jacksonville I’ll probably sit that one out. I don’t regret going but I walked away wishing for more. The performance was good not great and when you go in with high expectations it’s hard not to feel a little let down.
If you sew wondering what to wear, I went all out in a black gown and definitely felt overdressed. Most people were in more casual chic looks, think jeans, heels, and a cute top. If I were to go again (which I’m not) I’d aim for something stylish but comfortable. A casual night on the town type outfit would fit perfectly.
Would I Recommend It?
If you’re a fan of live orchestras and want to support Black art and culture then yes check them out at least once. A lot of people in my city gave the show a 10/10. Click here to see where they are next. If you’re more like me just manage your expectations and know that this isn’t your typical symphony experience. It’s a fusion of classical and contemporary but it still feels like it’s finding its groove.
Orchestra Noir is on the right track. With a few tweaks to song selection pacing and vibe they could absolutely deliver a show that’s not only entertaining but extraordinary.
Shara, WithLove
